Challenges
within and without: Rongmei Women’s Experiences in Society
- Lungsanliu P.
(A published article from The Place of Women in Naga Society published in 2018 by Naga Women Union Manipur and IWGIA)
The Rongmei Nagas
are one of the many indigenous Mongoloid communities living in three States of
Northeast India. They belong to the same cognate group known commonly by the
coined nomenclature, ‘Zeliangrong’, consisting of the Rongmei, Zeme, Liangmai
and Inpui/Puimei[1]. They have a common
homeland, sharing a common history and culture except for dialect variations;
and, taken together, they constitute one of the largest tribal groups having
the largest tract of compact contiguous land.[2] But their land has been trifurcated under the three States in the
Indian dominion, thereby, leaving the Zeliangrong people to several
disadvantages and remain backward wherever they are. The main homeland of the
Rongmei is the remote Western Hills of Manipur State of North East India now
called Tamenglong District while we find settlements of some Rongmei Nagas in
certain pockets of neighboring Districts and in the States of Assam and Nagaland.[3]
Rongmei population is estimated to be 1, 28, 137 settling in a total of 247
villages. There are 196 villages in Manipur, 36 in Assam and 15 in Nagaland.[4]
Meanwhile, according to Hill House Counting Assessment in 2010, out of the
total population of 1, 05,558 in Tamenglong District, the male population
accounted for 54,183, whereas the female population was 51,515.[5]We
can therefore assume that out of the approximate total Rongmei population of 1,
28,137, there may be around 60,000 Rongmei women in all.
Historical
Rendering
Since pre-colonial times, Meitei kings
had been associated with the hill tribals. The Rongmeis who joined the services
of these kings as labourers, security guards, maiba (seers), domestic helpers,
etc., settled down near them in the patches of land provided by them. When the
British came, they too used the tribal Rongmei as forced laborers and porters
to carry their luggage from one place to another without any remuneration. In
the early part of the 20th century, Haipou Jadonang, a Rongmei mystic, initiated
Naga Raj Movement against the British Colonial Rule. But
he was executed by the British in 1931 after which his successor Gaidinliu, a
teenage girl, organized her own army to fight the colonial rulers.
This uprising was suppressed by the
British who captured and imprisoned Gaidinliu. The Kabui, as they were called
in those days, were taken wherever the colonizer wanted for their requirement –
even to Calcutta, Sylhet in Bangladesh, Shillong, Gauhati and many parts of
British India. Many returned to nearby Manipur and Nagaland while a few stayed
behind in those places mentioned[6]
above, many of whom remain
unknown to the majority of the ‘mainland’ Rongmei. In the 1950s, the
Rongmeis later joined in the Nagas’ armed struggle for sovereignty started by A
Z Phizo. In the 1960s through the 1980s, the Zeliangrong people under the
leadership of Rani Gaidinliu demanded a separate administration within India
for the Zeliangrong Nagas by uniting their trifurcated territory. But the
movement was suspended in the larger interest of the Nagas’ struggle for
sovereignty.
In 2012, the Rongmei along with the
Zeme, Liangmai and Inpui have been separately recognized among the Scheduled
Tribes by the Government of India. Before this, the Rongmei and the Inpui have
been clubbed together with the common identity called Kabui while the Liangmai
and Zeme were identified as Kacha Naga which was a misnomer handed down by the
British. The Nagaland State Government recognized a section of Rongmei as one
of the indigenous tribes in 2012 though with several discriminations and
negative repercussions from other Naga tribes. In Assam there are about 36
Rongmei villages. Geographically divided Zeliangrongs including the Rongmei
were pushed to the fringe economically and politically; their aspiration for a
dignified life has remained unfulfilled. The tribals in Manipur State too have
been demanding separate administration and autonomy from the non-tribal
dominated government so as to be free from discrimination and to secure their
rights to their lands and resources.
In this article,
I am exploring the challenges and problems faced by Rongmei women keeping in
mind their status in society in the midst of the changes and struggles the
tribal people are living with.
Marginalization of Women: From Headhunting to
Modern Era
Headhunting, the kind of warfare performed only by men
folk was a practice that principally underlined all Naga traditional history.
The Rongmei term for headhunting days was Sangnaric. While men conspired
to go to war, women were the active agents in the sustenance of village life.
They engaged themselves in agriculture – ploughing, sowing, gleaning and
reaping, and performed all kinds of domestic works.[7].
Since womenfolk
did not participate in the institution of headhunting they were excluded from
the Pei which is till today the
highest decision-making body of any Rongmei village regarding issues of
warfare, land, forest, area of cultivation, dispute settlement, etc. It also
functions as the Village Court where its executive power is derived from unwritten customary laws and
traditional practices. Women’s
participation in the Village Pei/Court is permitted only when they are invited
or accused or called forth as witnesses. Whatever the case, even when allowed
to attend conflict resolution meetings in case of dispute, divorce or theft,
they are not allowed to speak unless they are asked to. Thus, there are
psychological and social barriers to their participation in village decision
making. Scholars like Wati Longchar pointed out that one of the factors
that marginalized tribal women in village polity is because of their
non-participation in “headhunting”.[8]
The coming of the
British and their modern influence upon life as well as the activities of
Christian missionaries towards the people of the North East India made them
realize the futility of this practice; and headhunting has been abandoned by both Christians and
non-Christians.
Women in Public Sphere
“A
woman is somebody with a wound”
Even
though the Rongmei have stopped the practice of headhunting, village
administration continues to be a male domain. The Village Pei (Council)
continues to function as the authority in socio-political, legal matters and implementation
of developmental schemes in the village level. Democratic elements have been
introduced to bring about changes in the village polity yet the democratization
of this institution was not accompanied with empowerment provision for women.
Many
men simply cannot imagine women’s inclusion in village or tribal polity. Asked
as to why women are excluded from leadership in village and tribal polity, the
elders’ justification is: Ntumei thu zamv phunghmei de (a woman is
somebody with a wound). Though not a common concept, people who question this
status quo have been supplied with this mockery about women’s monthly cycle to
justify the exclusion of women in public life and addressing in public. Many
Rongmei people including women themselves are of the view that women should not
address important gatherings be it social, political or religious ‘because it
is not our custom’. Men are the primary receivers and holders of information in
Rongmei society and women do not have equal access to information and resource
training to face new issues leaving them ignorant and unconfident for
leadership positions.
However,
there has been a historical step taken by one Rongmei woman in village
administration. Dithuanliu Kamei of
Machiang (Abungchiang) is the
first woman to lead a Village Council as its Chairperson. Machiang is a Rongmei village in Tamenglong
District, Manipur, with about 189 households. Dithuanliu became the Village
Chairperson in the milieu of a leadership conflict in the village council
regarding access to financial power and government schemes especially the NREGS
(National Rural Employment Generation Scheme). To prevent antagonism and
conflict among the villagers, her uncle who was then the Village Chairman
suggested that a woman’s leadership would be the best option for the sake of
peace at the juncture. Thus Dithuanliu, a young lady in her early
thirties and a graduate from the Nampou’s (Village Chief) family, was appointed
in September 2009 even though there were male members within her family capable
of the chairmanship.
After
completing her first tenure, she came to office for the second tenure by an
election in 2012 with 80% majority vote for her. She is actively involved in
bringing positive change in her village.
Through her initiative, her village got electrified and got a water
reservoir to relieve the water scarcity that had been necessitating the people
to walk half an hour down to collect a pot of water. She has done a commendable
advocacy on forest preservation as the means to conserve the depleting water
resource in her village. Even though there are no other women members in the
Village Council, she has sought to include women in various village development
committees. Men folk tend to ignore government’s directions on women’s quota in
village level bodies, but with her leadership, she has put all efforts to
include women members in Village Health and Sanitation Committee, School
Management Development Committee, Integrated Watershed Development Committee,
and Vigilance Monitoring Committee as per Government’s directions.
Dithuanliu
is actively involved with the wider Iring (Aling) Area Development Committee
which comprises 14 villages; she is one of the key representatives of the
people overseeing the Myanmar-Halflong Asian Highway crossing the region and is
the Treasurer of the All Tribal Chiefs Forum, Manipur. Even though she has
faced hardships as a woman having to complete tasks in time bound manner, she
affirms that she has received encouragement from all quarters and has never
been discriminated by people for being a woman while holding this post. Dithuanliu believes that both men and women
have equal intellect and with patience, determination and by being responsible,
women can take leadership in this generation.[9] Can the encouragement that
Dithuanliu receive from her male colleagues from within and outside her tribe
be an indicator that majority of the Rongmei are ready to accept women in
leadership position in the village level? The answer remains with the multitude
of Rongmei men in village polity.
Even though most Rongmei cannot accept women’s
involvement in traditional political institution, they cannot deny women’s
involvement in electoral politics because of the “opportunity of equal access to political
structures” provided by the Indian Constitution. Very few Rongmei women have risen above their
social horizons to participate in electoral politics. A recent development in this area is in
Lungbungjang area, Cachar, Assam where Ms. Lumgailiu Rongmei became the first
ever elected President of Gaon Panchayat (Lakhinagar G.P.)[10] from
Ramgaizang village on February 14, 2013. The Rongmei community in Assam has
been living as a minority group and never had the opportunity to get such
presidential post.[11]Guiliangliu Panmei is the only Rongmei woman in Manipur so far to
have contested, though she lost, in a State Legislative Assembly Election in
the year 2000 against other five male candidates.
On
the one hand, women do not join politics in the forefront because they are not
mentally empowered due to lack of awareness, lack of role models and support
and because of the attitude of the people, particularly of men who consider
women traditionally unfit for political and serious issues except to utilize
them in supportive roles. On the other hand, women do not get involved in
politics because they are poor.
Economic
empowerment is required to encourage women to involve in politics. The
responsibility of the home and the mindset of the society keep women from
freely involving in political leadership. These along with the present scenario
of relegating politics as a dirty game make women apathetic to politics. The
Rongmei women are yet to realize that to uplift the people especially
womenfolk, it is important for women’s voice to be heard and considered at the
decision and policy making level of governance rather than being at the
receiving end.
Personal Sphere:
Shifting Identities and Loss of Status
“Ntumei thu kakai khuang maek ge”
This is a common Rongmei saying which means ‘A woman has no
clan’.[12] A
woman’s clan identity is always in relation to men as a daughter, a wife or a
boy’s mother. She is considered the property of her paternal clan before her
marriage and of her husband’s clan after marriage. This is very clear in the
customary practice of settling adultery and rape cases in which the men
consider the act as an encroachment of their property. Penalty is demanded by
the male relatives from the culprit’s clan or relatives. Often they demand land
or money as penalty which in no way benefit the female victim.
Since the Rongmei practice
exogamy, patrilocal residence, and patrilineal family line of inheritance, boys are preferred to girls because of
the fear that there will be no one to carry on the family line without them.
After marriage the Rongmei woman loses her membership in her paternal
clan and in her community or church if she marries outside.
Earlier, before
the coming of western education, no written script was available. A married
woman attains double identity – she is her clan’s aluh (daughter) and
her husband’s clan’s kaipui (wife/mother). Now with the coming of the
written script and influence of the western patriarchal ideologies and gender
roles, married women have come to be formally addressed with their husband’s surnames
and no longer by their officially documented surnames – which can be understood
as an influence of colonialism. The community addresses a woman by her
husband’s surname without confirming if she has officially changed her name by
an affidavit. Earlier, most women did not have names formalized in official
documents but now many educated and professional women do have official names
from young age which they find inconvenient to keep changing after their
marriage. Even if a woman has officially changed her surname to that of her
husband’s, if or when she is divorced or widowed and happens to return to her
parental home, she has to change her surname again. And again, she has to
change her title if she gets remarried to another man. Thus the secondary status
accorded to women in the traditional social system is further worsened by
external influences. However, this
does not mean that a Rongmei woman is not cherished by her family and society.
Bride Price and a woman’s
value:
A woman’s value in Rongmei society becomes evident mainly
during her engagement and marriage. She is not easily given away in marriage by
her kinsmen. The boy’s kin are to respectfully approach the girl’s family for
her hand. In the past, the formal marriage proposal for Khaemthan or Holy marriage was usually done by bringing a pot of
rice wine and later followed by the payment of Bride Price agreed upon by the
two parties. The first installment of the Bride Price may be paid on the day of
engagement. Bride Price is usually paid
by the groom’s family to the bride’s parents in the form of paddy[13].
The bride price is determined by the status of the bride - whether she is a
virgin, a widow or a divorcee. After the bride price is fully paid, the girl’s
parents will arrange a customary function called Puatsumei (packing up for the bride) by cooking the meat of a
sizeable boar and sending to the groom’s house along with a sufficient quantity
of sticky rice beer. There are other
forms of Bride Price such as Mandu - which is paid to her family
if she has died before her Bride Price was cleared. Maigong Mann (Widow’s Price)
is paid by the late husband’s family to the widow’s parents if the former do
not want her to go back to her parents. If it is not settled, the widow can go
back home. Rou mann (Bone Price) is paid after the death of the wife by
the one who inherits her husband’s property. This is the last payment for a
bride which is not fixed but agreed between two parties.[14]
The woman’s kinfolk closely observe the way she is treated by
her husband’s family and clan. If she is mistreated, her relatives can raise
the issue of taking her back. Or in case the same clan comes with any other
marriage proposal in the future the girl’s clan can bring up such subject
against the man’s clan and even decide to withhold the girl’s hand in marriage.
Nowadays paying Bride Price is no longer a common practice due to economic
reasons but it has become a tradition to bring a boar to the girl’s home and
serve food on the day of the marriage proposal regardless of the type of
marriage. But expensive weddings are replacing these practices. While the
practice of Bride Price has become uncommon, the practice of Puatsumei (Packing up for the bride) is
religiously continued especially among Christians as a day of blessing a
daughter and arranging gifts/dowry to take to her new home.
Aluh Paumei:
During Phutuan Ngai (a festival celebrated after all the
ploughing of the field is done), one day is set for Aluh Paumei in which
families send food and rice wine to their married daughters’ families. This is a practice of honoring the married
daughters of the family whose Bride Prices have been received. The husband’s family would also cook special
food on the next day and give them in return.
This is not a common practice anymore but seems to have evolved into
something like Ningol Chakouba of the Meiteis in Manipur in which Rongmei
families especially in the Imphal Valley also invite all the married daughters
to their paternal homes for a feast.
People take great care to invite all the married daughters
during all important family events like weddings or plentiful harvest. Their
shares of the food or gifts are given according to tradition. These customary
gifts are received turn by turn by the womenfolk from their respective families
and clans as they grow older. The final and biggest honour an elderly woman
receives traditionally from her father or brothers is called Nap tann tiimei, a rare practice nowadays. After a plentiful harvest, her brothers would
send paddy (Nap tann) through
sons-in-law as much as they can carry on their backs to the eldest Aluh
(daughter/s) of the family.
Domestic Sphere:
Socially Assigned Roles
Domestically a
woman is overburdened with numerous roles and expectations assigned by the
society. The daily domestic chores, child rearing, and manual work at home have
been unconsciously considered by everyone to be purely women’s role. Even if
circumstances demand that men help in the domestic work, it is considered a
favor done to women. A daughter too has enormous roles in the domestic affairs.
Workload is not equally shared among boys and girls in the home. Girls do most
of the work while usually boys go out to roam and play. Womenfolk, being busy
with household activities do not have equal access to information, public life
and leadership as men do. This division of roles is one main reason that
hinders women’s social mobility and taking up of leadership status outside the
home. But domestic duties are invisible activities and are undervalued.
Nowadays women do
not simply stay at home but perform many activities that contribute to the
family’s economy. Gender disparity measures reveal that men’s responsibility is
shrinking in that men no longer go to war or actively work in the fields,
whereas women’s work frontier is expanding as they take over works
traditionally designated as ‘male domain’ besides being nurturers and
care-givers in the domestic realm.[15]This is becoming visible
too in Rongmei society.
And if a woman
works outside the home, she is not relieved of the household responsibilities
unlike for men. Today, women face what is called ‘double burden’ and ‘triple
burden’ of taking care of family members, household activities along with jobs
and obligations outside the home.
A man in
leadership position shared about how he was chided by a senior friend for
carrying his kid around with him, saying that it was unbecoming to his status.
Such is the attitude of the older generation. Still, it is encouraging to see
some young couples working out between themselves in the care of children while
women go to work.
Regarding
decision making, a woman may take most decisions relating to household matters
but hardly does a wife make a final decision with regard to the children’s
career, procurement of major assets, choice of faith or religion, village
matters or political candidate to support without the consent and decision of
her husband. She is expected to blindly follow her husband’s decision or that
of his clan. A woman tells of her experience:
My
husband’s clan and my parent’s clan were on the opposite sides of a land
dispute. When the conflict became serious the village Pei got divided into two. The dissenting group formed a new Village
Council. Eventually the Church got split into two. As Government funds and
schemes got divided between the two village bodies, I am expected to blindly
follow my husband’s family or clan decision in the matter of political
candidate in the MLA(Member of Legislative Assembly) and MP (Member of
Parliament) elections, where to cultivate or earn my NREGS wages(100 days wages
under National Rural Employment Generation Scheme) and which church or
denomination to go for worship. When I did not go by their decision, they told
me that I could go back to my parents. To prevent further chaos and for the
sake of my children, I submitted to their diktat.
Economic Sphere
Mere Custodians
of Male Property
Rongmei society
follows the patrilineal system of inheritance in which the youngest son
inherits the ancestral home. The father can distribute his land and properties
to his other children as he wishes. Traditionally women are not entitled to
inherit their parent’s immovable assets. If a man dies without a male child,
his nearest kinsman will inherit his properties even if there are daughters.[16] As long as she is living
in her parents’ home, a daughter may utilize her family land and property but
she leaves them all behind when she gets married and becomes a caretaker of her
husband’s family assets. She may be gifted moveable property such as paddy,
furniture, jewellery and clothes but traditionally immoveable assets are
divided among her brothers.
However in some cases a
woman is given a patch of land or forest – a rambou – by her father or brothers if they own enough land and so
desire to give. Such cases are more common if a woman returns as a widow,
divorcee or has a husband without land to settle or has no share of forest area
(rambou) to depend on for livelihood.
In most occasions such land will not go to her husband’s family but may be
taken back in the future when she dies. Or it may be passed on to her married
daughter if she so needs it. But with land becoming scarce, these practices are
becoming fewer as men folk increase their grip on their landholdings in the
backdrop of the rising value of land against increasing population and human
wants. There are cases of male relatives selling off land allotted to the
daughter without her or her immediate kin’s knowledge creating discord among
family members. Changes in social and economic structure and cohesiveness are
diminishing these traditional practices of care and respect for the Rongmei
women.
A widow is just the custodian of her husband’s landed
property if her son is still a minor. Another
stark reality regarding the discrimination of Rongmei women surfaces in this
area of inheritance and ownership of property. If a woman has no son, her life is more insecure in her
husband’s home. A recent incident of Ramgailiu[17]
speaks of the precarious condition of the multitude of women at the mercy of
men brought up in a patriarchal society.
After the death
of her husband, the brothers-in-law of Ramgailiu started acting indifferently
towards her. They told her that since she and her husband had no boy-offspring,
the daughters are not entitled to the property. They started envying their home
entitled to her late husband. The men and their wives started treating her
badly that she knew they wanted her to leave. So she decided at last to return
to her parents’ household. Other two similar cases happened in that same
village the following year.
Even if a woman
brings up her child born out of wedlock because the man is already married or
had denied the baby as his, after some years the man’s kin can come and claim
the child by giving some amount of money to the woman. The child can continue to live with its
mother but from then on he/she will be counted as belonging to the father’s
clan. This payment is called “Nakuanlan
tiimei”.[18]
Someone sadly
pointed out saying: Women do not have the right to own even their children
which is the fruit of their painful labor. There is no law to protect their
rights. There is therefore, nothing that a woman can claim as theirs either in
their fathers’ house or in their husbands’ except a little amount of moveable
properties given by her parents at the time of marriage. This kind of treatment
is inhumane. It is a serious issue that should be taken into special consideration
by legislators of all levels as well as by people at large in order to improve
the condition of women.[19]
Few women have started taking up their case to the law courts
with the help of some NGOs. For the first time in 2010-2011, a woman fought for
the custody of her children while settling her divorce. She won the case which
allowed her to keep her children if they wish to go to her. Two of her children
are living with her. Thereafter, some other women who have been widowed or
abandoned by their husbands are following suit and seeking legal help for the
custody of their children as well as financial sanction for their upbringing.
Slowly women are turning to family courts away from customary law which has no
sanction for them anymore.
Religious Sphere
The Glass Ceiling
in Church Ministry:
The majority
(approx. 80%) of Rongmei have been converted to Christianity with the remaining
still following the traditional ancestral religion. The year 2014 marked the commemoration of 100 years of
Christianity among Rongmei people. People claim to have come out from the ‘dark
days of headhunting into the light’ through the Christian Gospel. But along
with Christianity came the Western male-oriented ideologies and interpretation
of the Bible thereby curtailing women ministries as well as involvement in
decision making bodies.
Churches have been encouraging both men and women to undergo
theological training in preparation for church ministries. There are around 100
theologically trained women[20] in Rongmei churches in Manipur who are as qualified as their
male counterparts. But the notion of ‘Women-lead-women-and-children’ still
holds strong among the churches as a result of the influence left behind by
pioneer leaders and evangelists groomed in fundamental conservative teachings.
Some churches do not give platform for women to address the general
congregation of the church.
Within the Baptist Church which is the largest denomination
followed by the Rongmei, there is a record of 61 male ordained as Reverends[21]
but there has been no female pastor and no ordained women Minister as yet.
Leadership in the churches, Board of Deacons,[22]
the various departments and associations are dominated by the men except for
the Women Department and Sunday school department. At
a snail's pace, we are witnessing women being inducted into leadership roles in
the local church. Neikanlong
Baptist Church in Imphal has two deaconesses out of five. Emmanuel Baptist
Church and Tamenglong Baptist Church in Tamenglong town have one deaconess each
as token representatives. There are no women as church Secretaries or Youth
Pastors. Tamenglong Baptist Church which is the biggest Rongmei Church
appointed women to the posts of Youth Worker, Sunday School Superintendent and
Mission Secretary.[23]
Again at the
Association[24]
level, in the history of RNBA (Rongmei Naga Baptist Association in Manipur)
with an official record of 7000-7500 baptized women, no woman has ever led as
Executive Secretary. The Chairperson or Secretary of all different departments except
Women Department and evangelists are all men. The topic of women’s leadership
is an anathema to many people’s ears. Voices in favor of this issue are still
in the periphery. Some churches impose head covering upon women during worship.
Previous RNBA Women Secretaries in the past experienced discrimination to the
extent of being made to sit among the children in some village churches during
official team visits while other male members were invited to sit on the podium
along with the pastors and deacons.[25] However this extent of
discrimination is not experienced by the present Women Secretary. One progress
experienced by women in ministry is that most churches are giving their pulpit
for women to preach except one or two Rongmei churches.[26]
The biggest gathering of Rongmei Baptist women under RNBA
happens every ten years on the occasion of the RNBA Women Conference. Only in
the 3rd Women Conference in 2006, speakers have started highlighting
about women empowerment such as the need for 50-50 in decision making process
and equality. This triggered negative responses from the older conservative
male leaders. In the 4th Women Conference in 2015, women ordination
has been generally highlighted in the gathering by a resource person. Leaders
sensed that the time is not yet ripe for a thorough discussion and conclusive
public statement. But the discourse has been started and there seems to be
general awareness and acceptance among the educated womenfolk and few male
leaders.[27] In the
ongoing consultations conducted by the RNBA Women Department to bring out its
Vision and Mission statements and future strategies, the leaders discussed upon
the need to be ready with women who can be recommended for ordination as and
when the ordination of women is accepted by the church.[28]
In 2014 during
the Annual Business Session of Tamenglong Baptist Church, some members of the
Women Department raised the agenda on women ordination for a pioneer women
leader. The responses from the men were as usual: pointing to biblical passages
written in early Judeo-Greek context that restrict women’s leadership. When we
tried to sustain the discussion, some deacons became very agitated and
threatened that ‘if this discussion is not stopped, we will start quarrelling.”
Every now and then, some people have tried to raise this issue of women as
pastors and ordained ministers in the RNBA churches but the majority of the
men-folk strongly oppose it even though they have no problem with women
leadership in secular offices. The issue continues to be hushed up by leaders
for the sake of church unity.
The seven Rongmei Baptist churches in Nagaland come under
the umbrella of RBA. Due to lack of
trained ministers in these churches, women are comparatively taking significant
leadership roles. The key post of Secretary of the Development Department of
RBA which is doing a major role in uplifting the poor Rongmei villagers in
Nagaland is a woman – Akeina Gonmei. A woman
(Mathiuthuanliu) has also served as Mission Secretary. There are women serving
as church secretaries and Sunday School Superintendents and deacons.[29] Kariugailiu Kamei Koza,
who served as Associate Pastor in Rongmei Baptist Church, Kohima, for a term
was the first woman associate pastor among the Rongmei Nagas.[30]Rev. Dr. A.G. Kamei in Nagaland is the first Rongmei woman to
be ordained as a Reverend but it was not given by Rongmei Church.[31]Meanwhile
in the inter-cultural setting, we have two Rongmei women Gaigongmei Gangmei
serving as Associate Pastor of Zeliangrong Christian Fellowship Delhi and Ms
Ninguang Kamei serving as the Pastor of Rehoboth Church in Delhi at present.
When this news was posted in Rongmei social networking sites, it sparked a
heated debate and criticism from Rongmei men mainly from fundamental circles.[32] In these debates
regarding women’s position in the church, people continually quote the biblical
passages indicating the Bible does not allow women to lead or be above men.
Fundamental
theological and biblical interpretations are to be blamed for this ‘glass
ceiling’ that discriminates against women from serving according to their
calling and capacity. Some men and women who studied in colleges teaching
contextual theology have been exposed to gender issues and are open to women’s
partnership in church leadership. But most Rongmei men and women opt to go to
fundamental colleges due to lack of guidance and finance. Whoever raises these
issues is considered to be diluting the church with false teachings and thus
many continue toeing the middle line.
Society's tolerance to violence against women
Rongmei society seems to have become tolerant and apathetic
to crimes and violence against women. Wife battering by drunken husbands,
rising rape cases in society, constant fear of sexual assault by men in
conflict situation brought about by our Naga people’s struggle for sovereignty,
clashes between the Indian military and the Naga undergrounds, infighting among
the Naga underground factions, all these place women in vulnerable situation.
There have been several rape incidents of Rongmei women including small baby
girls. Wife battering by inebriated husbands are considered issues between
husband and wife that need no interference from relatives or society. ‘I suffer
for the sake of my children’ is what most of the exploited women say. Sexual
assault and rape cases within the community are considered inter-clan matters
to be solved by concerned relatives without any legal consolation for the
victim.[33]
The customary laws enforced in these cases are hardly in favor of the female
victims but are taken advantage of by the male relatives for their
self-interests like demanding land from the condemned party.
In 2012, following the rape of a Rongmei woman chilly hawker
by four men in a truck on the intervening night of March 21 and 22, valley
based activist groups came to Tamenglong to show their solidarity by conducting
a rally. The turn-out of the local people was so dismal that they went away
disappointed with the apathetic nature of the Rongmei public.
Even the religious bodies/ churches remain as silent
spectators most of the time. They never empathize with the victims or show
their solidarity. Society tries to find fault with their behavior and further
stigmatize them. During the case of the five girls in domestic helpers’ service
in Malaysia and Singapore who became victims of sexual harassment but were
rescued by Women and Child Rights groups, church people gathered where they
were sheltered to admonish the already traumatized women. They even attempted
to give a press release emphasizing that women like these should not bring bad
name to our people again in this manner.[34]
Rongmei Women Confronting Challenges
Women’s voices
for women’s rights have been raised every now and then among the academic
circles in writings and women conferences. But there has been no strong and
sustained effort for action so far. Surely the awareness is growing among the
young women through education and social media. At the grassroots, women are
organizing themselves into Self Help Groups (SHGs) in order to help one another
economically by borrowing at low interests from the group money rather than
from money lenders at high interest rates thereby helping towards breaking the
cycle of poverty. Several NGOs have been helping in forming SHGs by providing
initial capital along with gender awareness seminars but these groups need
constant encouragement and monitoring.
Every locality
has a women’s society or network. When alcoholism is rampant especially during
election time, the womenfolk form themselves into groups and take turns to
position themselves at key locations to check drunkenness and brawling, drunken
driving, smuggling of liquor and sale of intoxicants (this is called nisha
bandh). Sometimes they also ransack illicit liquor hubs, capture drug
peddlers and drug users and even check gambling and revelry.
Zeliangrong
Tanpui
Rongmei women
have been engaged for years with their Zeme, Liangmai and Puimei sisters in
working for the welfare of the society through an organization called
Zeliangrong Tanpui also called Zeliangrong Women Front. It has been involved in
maintaining peace in Zeliangrong areas, spearheading the Nisha Bandh
movement, preservation and promotion of arts and culture and organizing
demonstrations, rallies and seminars according to the need of the situation.
Since its inception in 1982, Zeliangrong Tanpui has seized approximately 5000
(Five Thousand) litres of illicit country liquor from different places in
Tamenglong district and handed the people over to the local police station for
taking legal action.
Besides,
in the wake of ethnic conflict among the hill tribes of Manipur since 1992 the
organization has in two occasions detected the excesses of the Indian security
forces in its action of counter insurgency and against the violation of human
rights. The Zeliangrong Women Organization has sponsored public rally against
the 11 Bihar Regiment for their heinous crimes of killing an innocent
cultivator from Tamenglong Village in November, 1993. The cases of security
forces’ excesses at Longmai and Khumji Kaiba were also fought by the
Zeliangrong women where they confronted with the security forces for their
inhuman treatment of the innocent public and killing one disabled Namjokpou in
the name of counter insurgency operation. When the Ahu/Barak Range Zeliangrong
villages were under siege and were subjected to atrocious torture for a week by
the 21st Rajputana Rifles in August 1995 and when all means had
failed including the civil administration to rescue our people in distress, the
Zeliangrong Tanpui strongly came out and confronted the army authorities and
rescued more than 60 victims and took them to the hospitals.[35]On the night of 31st October 2012, the women of
Tamenglong spearheaded the torch bearing peace rally to protest against
factional shootings in Tamenglong town area.[36]
Rongmei Lu Phuam (Rongmei Women’s Organization)
Rongmei Lu Phuam
(RLP) which was formed in 2004 consists of all Rongmei women from the three
States of Assam, Manipur and Nagaland and it was led by Panti Gonmei as
President, Ph.Amunliu Gangmei as Vice President, Atina Gangmei as Secretary and
Priscilla Panmei as Asst. Secretary and G. Khamsinliu as the Treasurer. The
Rongmei Women Organization/RLP is at present led by Panti Gonmei as President and Aram Pamei as Secretary.
Their
activities are mentioned below.
1. RLP/RWO
has been involved in working for justice towards various rape victims. Till
date, it has involved itself in fighting for seven rape cases in both the hill
and valley. These works consist of sending fact finding teams, documentations,
helping to file charge sheets against the culprits and condemning the acts
through press releases and thereby pressurising the government to take lawful
action against the culprits. It also provided financial help to the needy
victims or sought compensation for the victims. The officials have witnessed
court hearings and kept track of the proceedings.
2. The President, Secretary and other officers
have been part of 17 Fact Finding Team Visits in many cases of excesses, murder
and human rights violations against civilians by Indian army and insurgent groups.
3. The
Organization has besides its own Conferences, organized several seminars and
workshops on Mediation Skills, Non-Violence and Conflict Transformation, and a
Friendly Football Match. It has felicitated 6 outstanding Rongmei women. In
2009, during the First RLP Conference a book called Rongmei Lu Di was
published as souvenir. During this program, competitions in March Pass parade,
Traditional Dancing Dress, Traditional Wedding Dress Model, Theme Song Competition
in Traditional Tune, Football, Solo and Group Song, Debate and Games and Sports
were organized. A Memorial Stone was erected in commemoration of the event.
4. Rongmei Lu Phuam has been engaged in brokering peace
and negotiation among conflicting groups and it took major part in taking care
of deceased bodies during conflict and provided relief to refugees affected by
inter-tribal clashes between the Zeme and Dimasa in Assam and aided victims of
anti-conversion movements in various Rongmei villages.
5. RLP has been actively involved in campaigning against
Tipaimukh Dam, Oil Exploration in tribal areas and many other issues.[37]
Rongmei women and their associations are the guardians
for the well being and harmony of the community. But their activities
have been mainly community-oriented to solve day to day crisis in the society.
Their activism has also been in
support of the larger tribal bodies which fight against armed forces, against
construction of mega dams, mining, and Land Use Policies and for alternative
political arrangements for Nagas. The tribal apex bodies like Zeliangrong
Union, Zeliangrong Baudi, Zeliangrong Youth Front and Rongmei Council are all
male dominated organizations. Women’s organizations such as Zeliangrong Women
Union, Zeliangrong Pui Baudi (recently formed) and Rongmei Lu Phuam are
understood as women’s wing of these apex bodies even though they may have been
formed independently. They are expected to speak in the same tune as the
‘parent’ bodies. If they raise gender rights issues, they get minimal support
from these bodies. Women’s rights are taken as minor and individual issues in
the context of the wider issues of the community and tribe.
In the overall
tribal struggle in North East India, women’s contribution to the struggle of
our people as a whole are often not recognized or acknowledged. Women’s
concerns have been ignored and forgotten in the cause of the wider struggle and
all policies that have been made for the tribals have overlooked their plight.
Rongmei women are only beginning to be aware of this discrimination.
The Way Ahead
Rongmei women
like many other indigenous women do not see themselves as victims. Faced with
discrimination, they have been forced to develop skills and strategies for
their own survival, and for the survival of their people and culture. Rongmei
women’s activism has not yet taken the shape of a sustained women’s rights
movement. Sometimes women’s issues were taken up
on International Women’s Day, etc. But Rongmei women are yet to actively take
their voices and issues of women’s Right to Equality to the level of
legislation. No particular strategy seems to have been formulated to take the
issues of women to the legislative level except sensitization on women’s
condition and rights or voices raised against discrimination of women now and
then in few public and social media forums or write-ups by some concerned
individuals. Unity, networking and
sorority among women, long term strategy and organized action are the need of
the hour.
On the one hand,
the majority of Rongmei women are unaware of their situation and rights though
they are actively contributing to the social and economic life of the society.
On the other hand, many women are mentally empowered through education but are
hindered from participating in the decision making process due to men-made
social boundaries such as patriarchal customary practices and cultural roles
and fundamental religious teaching.
The way forward
would be to gain the support of men by creating awareness among the opinion
makers such as the community leaders, teachers, social activists, church
leaders, by raising awareness through education and by encouraging women to
involve in changing the policies and practices that marginalize us. Women are
often placed in a situation where they must deal with new challenges and
effects without an informed perspective. They need equal access to information
and training activities from concerned bodies so that a condition where the men
are the sole primary receivers and holders of information does not persist.
Training and education will provide us with the skill to develop
professionally, economically and involve politically. Attempts that allow for
women’s input and participation need to be scheduled according to their
convenience keeping in mind the lives they lead and roles to fulfill as care
givers and nurturers.
Awareness of and change in the status of women need to begin
with the church which is the most powerful institution in today’s Christian
dominated Rongmei society. The Rongmei churches need to open their doors for
women as equal partners in the church ministry. Teachers of religion need to
change their rigid mindset and learn how to apply the liberal message of the
Bible contextually. Customary laws which depend on oral traditions need to be
modified so that no section of our society is discriminated and then codified
according to the change of the times.
Above all, from the examples of women like Rani Gaidinliu who
rose above her society to lead her people for freedom, and also of women like
Dithuanliu Kamei, Lumgailiu Rongmei and other women leaders in the past and
present time, we can still hopefully say that we can overcome whatever barriers that exist and rise above
the male dominated society if women are united, possess courage and intellect,
and our men supportive.
[1]
The prefix of Puimei was not included in the ‘Zeliangrong’ nomenclature coined
in 1947. Because of this the Puimei later moved away from being a part of Zeliangrong organizations.
[3]
The Zeliangrongs are found in large number under Dima-Hasao District of Assam,
Peren district of Nagaland and Tamenglong District of Manipur as a unit while
Zeliangrong villages in Loktak Project are under Churachandpur district of
Manipur. The westernmost Zeliangrong villages are found in Cachar District of
Assam, while its adjoining villages fall under Jiribam Sub-division of Imphal
East. Over 88 villages are found in Manipur Valley and its foothill, under
different administrative set ups – Imphal East, Imphal West, Senapati,
Bishnupur and Thoubal. In Nagaland, pockets of Zeliangrong villages are found
in Kohima and Dimapur.
[4]
“Rongmei Population (Annexure B)” in Hundred
Years with Christ (1914-2014): A Commemorative volume of Rongmei Christian
Centenary Celebration-2014, p.286-289.
[5] K.P. Kamiuthuan,
“The Rongmei Naga” in A Gift to Churches: Souvenir of RNBA Silver Jubilee, Dec.
9-11,2011, edited by Thuanliang Gangmei, 189-190. According to this Assessment
in 2010 Rongmei population in Manipur was 1,05,558 in Tamenglong District alone
with an additional figure of about 45,400 from Greater Imphal, 10,500 in
Nagaland, and 1,230 in Assam with a total population of 1,62,668.
[6]Gairiangmei
Naga, answer to a query posted by the author on Rongmei Naga Facebook Group on
August 11, 2014.Accessed on August 12, 2014.
[7]
Eyingbeni Humtsoe, “Women’s Experience of “Sorrow” as a Source for Doing
Theology from Naga Perspective” in No More Sorrow in God’s Garden of
Justice: Tribal Women Doing Theology, Women Study Series No. 4 edited by
Limatula Longkumer,(Jorhat: Women Study Department,ETC, 2007), p 4.
[8]
Wati Longchar, “Headhunting: A Socio-religious Factor for Oppression of Women
in North East India,” Good News for North
East India. A Theoligical Reader, ed. Renthy Keitzar, (Guwahati: The
Christian Literature Centre, 1995), 198,199.
[9]Telephonic
conversation with Dithuanliu Gangmei, Village Chairman Abungchiang on 27th
January, 2015.
[10]Local governance in Assam has a three-tier set up - Gaon
Panchayat with 6000 - 10,000 Population; Anchalik Panchayat (at the block
level) and Mahkuma Parishad at the sub-divisional level.
[11]
A Facebook post by Puanthan Dangmei
in Zeliangrong Naga Facebook group on April 30, 2013.
[12]
Her clan is determined by her marriage.
[13]
The bride price varies from village to village and may range between 80
measures (buanh) to 200 measures of paddy. It may be paid in installments.
[14]
Dichamang Pamei, Liberty to Captives,
A ZBCC Platinum Jubilee Publication, (n.p.:n.d.), p. 42.
[15]
UA Shimray, ‘Women’s Work in Naga Society:Household work, workforce
Participation and Division of Labour”. http://www.jstor.org/discover/10.2307/4414929?uid=3738256&uid=2129&uid=2&uid=70&uid=4&sid=21101871413301,
accessed on June 12, 2013 at 3.30 pm.
[16]Op
cit., Thuanliang Gangmei ed., “Women in RNBA”, 64.
[17]
Name has been changed.
[18]
Jimmy Pamei, Inriangluang Village, September 19, 2015.
[19] Thuanliang Gangmei ed., “Women in RNBA”, in Souvenir
RNBA Youth Conference, 2008, 65.
[20]
Telephone conversation with Ms. Gaimuna, Women
Secretary, RNBA, 2nd April, 2013.
[21]
Thaikhui Rongmei, “Who’s Who and Important Events”, in Hundred Years with Christ (1914-2014) A Commemorative volume of Rongmei
Christian Centenary Celebration-2014,202-206.
[22]
The Board of Deacons can be called the main decision making body of the Baptist
Church.
[23]
Ms. Gaikhuiliu and Ningreiliu Panmei served as Youth Workers/Directors for a
term each; Ms. Abuan Riamei is the Sunday School Superintendent and Ms.
Gaihiamliu Panmei has been recently appointed as Mission Secy. at Tamenglong
Baptist Church, Manipur.
[24]The Baptist churches come together under
a parent body like the Rongmei Naga Baptist Association (RNBA) in Manipur,
Rongmei Baptist Association,Nagaland (RBAN) and Regular Fundamental Baptist
Churches (RFBC) in Assam. The writer has focused on the Baptist denomination
and regrets for not presenting the scenario in other denominations due to lack
of information.
[25]
Interview with Azanliu, Former Women Secretary, RNBA, at Tamenglong on 3rd
Jan 2010.
[26]
Telephone conversation with Gaimuna, Women Secretary RNBA.
[27] Telephone
conversation Pouguiliu Pamei, President of Women Society, Tamenglong Baptist
Church and leader in RNBA Women Dept. and
30th June 2016.
[28]
Gaimuna, Women Secretary RNBA, 10th June, 2016.
[29] Lungdapou
Riamei, Youth Secretary, RBAN, Correspondence,
Zalukie, 16th January, 2010.
[30]
Ajuna Pame (ed), “Kariuganliu Kamei Koza” in Rongmei Lu Di,13.
[31]
A.G. Kamei is ordained by her institution.
[32]A
Facebook post by Kadima Gangmei on June 12, 2014.
[33]There was however
an incident in which a man who
raped a woman was beaten to death by his relatives unintentionally in
Tamenglong.
[34]
As told by an NGO worker.
[35]“A Brief Report
of The Zeliangrong Tanpui” presented by Ashinliu Remmei, President and D.
Songdiliu Secretary, Zeliangrong Tanpui, Tamenglong, November 2,1995.
[36]Benjamin Gondaimei posted in
in Women of Zeliangrong Facebook Group. Accessed on June 15, 2014.
[37]Aram Pamei, “Rongmei Lu Phuam Kahoumei Khatni Taan Tanpat
Kanmei,” A Report presented on 5 March 2014 at Rongmei Lu Phuam (RLP) Executive
Committee Meeting held at RLP Office, Tarung.
No comments:
Post a Comment